Hanks did a good job on the screenplay and in the title role, even though he might be a tad bit old for the role of CDR Krause, the destroyer's captain and commander of the convoy's escorts. It's a pretty good look at the grittiness of the Battle of the Atlantic, which was the longest battle of the war. The movie takes place in the Black Pit, the area of the North Atlantic that was not covered by land-based ASW aircraft.[1]
Now, some technical quibbles:
But I digress.
The scenes shot on the ship didn't show any effects of sea motion, which makes sense, because the Kidd is moored/drydocked in Baton Rouge. They got a lot of stuff right, but they occaisionally messed up on the orders to the helm and lee helm.[2]. And the captain wasn't returning salutes, which, given that all captains in 1942 had graduated from The Boat Skool, was not accurate.
The movie didn't underplay or highlight the racism of the day, when Black men were limited to being mess attendants.
The movie, of course, is a CGI-fest, but there was probably no other way to do it. If you have Apple TV+, ot'swell worth the time.
____________
[1] Among the many things that "Bomber Harris should be rotting in Hell for, his extreme resistance to providing aircraft to Costal Command for long-range patrols, let alone equipping them with airborne radar, should be near the top.
[2] The "lee helm" is the engine-order telegraph.
Still nowhere as good as The Cruel Sea.
ReplyDeletehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cruel_Sea_(1953_film)